Showing posts with label OSU Blogosphere 2010. Show all posts
Showing posts with label OSU Blogosphere 2010. Show all posts
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Obama: Bring Troops Home, Support Veterans
President Obama’s first State of the Union address last night concluded with Obama noting the administration’s “largest increase in investments for veterans in decades — last year.” Obama did not directly address the infamous ‘culture of denial’ our veterans endure at the U.S. Dept of Veterans Affairs, but he did commit to a specific policy in Iraq and Afghanistan “so … our troops can begin to come home.”
Below are Obama remarks pertaining directly to veterans affairs from his address.
… And in Afghanistan, we’re increasing our troops and training Afghan security forces so they can begin to take the lead in July of 2011, and our troops can begin to come home. (Applause.) We will reward good governance, work to reduce corruption, and support the rights of all Afghans — men and women alike. (Applause.) We’re joined by allies and partners who have increased their own commitments, and who will come together tomorrow in London to reaffirm our common purpose. There will be difficult days ahead. But I am absolutely confident we will succeed.
As we take the fight to al Qaeda, we are responsibly leaving Iraq to its people. As a candidate, I promised that I would end this war, and that is what I am doing as President. We will have all of our combat troops out of Iraq by the end of this August. (Applause.) We will support the Iraqi government — we will support the Iraqi government as they hold elections, and we will continue to partner with the Iraqi people to promote regional peace and prosperity. But make no mistake: This war is ending, and all of our troops are coming home. (Applause.)
Tonight, all of our men and women in uniform — in Iraq, in Afghanistan, and around the world –- they have to know that we — that they have our respect, our gratitude, our full support. And just as they must have the resources they need in war, we all have a responsibility to support them when they come home. (Applause.) That’s why we made the largest increase in investments for veterans in decades — last year. (Applause.) That’s why we’re building a 21st century VA. And that’s why Michelle has joined with Jill Biden to forge a national commitment to support military families. (Applause.) …
Source:veteranstoday.com/
The State of Obama
In the wake of the Massachusetts results, there was a lot of chatter among conservative pundits about whether Barack Obama was even capable of executing a strong pivot to the center. Jay Cost was uncertain, Jim Geraghty was skeptical — and Jonathan Last, provocatively, argued that Obama was as likely to prove as stubborn about course corrections as George W. Bush.
For my part, I figured that a pivot to the center was the plan all along — or at least, that it became the plan once Obama’s poll numbers started to sag, and the chances of steamrolling the whole Democratic agenda through Congress in his first two years evaporated. As soon as health care passed, securing his legacy as the true heir of L.B.J. and F.D.R., I assumed that Obama would start channeling the post-1994 Bill Clinton, and spend the run-up to the 2010 midterms talking round-the-clock about jobs, the deficit, and the middle class. And I assumed that he’d be good at it. Not Clinton good, maybe, but impressive all the same. He’s too much of a pragmatist, in the end, and too savvy a politician not to be able to execute a centrist turn when the situation seems to call for it.
But this pivot, if that’s what the White House planned, was contingent on a health care victory. Instead, the legislation has entered a weird political limbo, and taken Obama’s presidency into limbo with it.
That was certainly the impression left by tonight’s State of the Union, which struck me as the speech of a President who doesn’t know what narrative he’s selling. The eloquence was there, but the tone veered wildly — now self-critical, now self-justifying; now scolding, now conciliatory — and so did the substance. At times Obama channeled Clinton, promising to slash the deficit, touting his tax cuts, and floating small-bore, middle class-friendly policy proposals: Child care tax credits, student loan reforms, etc. At times he gave us a taste of what a McCain administration would have been like, pledging spending freezes, championing nuclear power, and bashing earmarks. Then he went populist on the banks, and played the economic nationalist on exports and energy — and, if you listened closely, on campaign finance as well. And large swathes of speech struck exactly the same notes (“don’t blame us, blame Bush” chief among them) that the White House has been striking all year, to diminishing returns.
As for health care — well, I’m still not sure what to make of the health care section, which seemed too tepid if the White House is still hoping to pass the legislation as it is, and too combative if they want to explore a smaller and more bipartisan bill. Yesterday Ezra Klein suggested that the White House has acted confused and uncertain on health care because it is confused and uncertain. That was exactly the sense tonight’s speech left me with — and presidential uncertainty can’t be a good thing for the legislation’s prospects.
I don’t mean to be too hard on the president: All State of the Unions tend to sprawl, and some of the tonal and substantive dissonances I’m picking up on here are inevitable in a big, detailed, cover-the-waterfront kind of address. But if there was ever a night to tighten things up, to narrow the focus, and to figure out a few big things you want to stay and a couple of big impressions you want to leave, then this was it. I came into the S.O.U. with two major questions: How is the administration going to handle health care in the wake of Massachusetts, and what kind of leader is Obama going to become if he has to govern amid a Republican resurgence? The President said a lot of things tonight, but he didn’t really answer either one of them.
Source:douthat.blogs.nytimes.com/
For my part, I figured that a pivot to the center was the plan all along — or at least, that it became the plan once Obama’s poll numbers started to sag, and the chances of steamrolling the whole Democratic agenda through Congress in his first two years evaporated. As soon as health care passed, securing his legacy as the true heir of L.B.J. and F.D.R., I assumed that Obama would start channeling the post-1994 Bill Clinton, and spend the run-up to the 2010 midterms talking round-the-clock about jobs, the deficit, and the middle class. And I assumed that he’d be good at it. Not Clinton good, maybe, but impressive all the same. He’s too much of a pragmatist, in the end, and too savvy a politician not to be able to execute a centrist turn when the situation seems to call for it.
But this pivot, if that’s what the White House planned, was contingent on a health care victory. Instead, the legislation has entered a weird political limbo, and taken Obama’s presidency into limbo with it.
That was certainly the impression left by tonight’s State of the Union, which struck me as the speech of a President who doesn’t know what narrative he’s selling. The eloquence was there, but the tone veered wildly — now self-critical, now self-justifying; now scolding, now conciliatory — and so did the substance. At times Obama channeled Clinton, promising to slash the deficit, touting his tax cuts, and floating small-bore, middle class-friendly policy proposals: Child care tax credits, student loan reforms, etc. At times he gave us a taste of what a McCain administration would have been like, pledging spending freezes, championing nuclear power, and bashing earmarks. Then he went populist on the banks, and played the economic nationalist on exports and energy — and, if you listened closely, on campaign finance as well. And large swathes of speech struck exactly the same notes (“don’t blame us, blame Bush” chief among them) that the White House has been striking all year, to diminishing returns.
As for health care — well, I’m still not sure what to make of the health care section, which seemed too tepid if the White House is still hoping to pass the legislation as it is, and too combative if they want to explore a smaller and more bipartisan bill. Yesterday Ezra Klein suggested that the White House has acted confused and uncertain on health care because it is confused and uncertain. That was exactly the sense tonight’s speech left me with — and presidential uncertainty can’t be a good thing for the legislation’s prospects.
I don’t mean to be too hard on the president: All State of the Unions tend to sprawl, and some of the tonal and substantive dissonances I’m picking up on here are inevitable in a big, detailed, cover-the-waterfront kind of address. But if there was ever a night to tighten things up, to narrow the focus, and to figure out a few big things you want to stay and a couple of big impressions you want to leave, then this was it. I came into the S.O.U. with two major questions: How is the administration going to handle health care in the wake of Massachusetts, and what kind of leader is Obama going to become if he has to govern amid a Republican resurgence? The President said a lot of things tonight, but he didn’t really answer either one of them.
Source:douthat.blogs.nytimes.com/
State of the Blogosphere 2010
As we’ve come to expect from President Obama, tonight’s State of the Union message was a model of coherent argument and organization. In response, here’s a mishmash of reactions from sundry corners of the blogosphere:
— As the president went through his initial laundry list of wishes and causes, Josh Marshall of TPM came to think liberals might not be in such dire political straits: “Listening to this litany, I’m reminded how Republicans are on the wrong side – just politically, let alone on policy — of most signature issues in a populist economic moment. I think there were zero Republicans standing up on any part of Obama’s financial reform agenda — something that polls exceedingly well in addition to being good public policy.”
— Ramesh Ponnuru of National Review was struck by this passage: “The House has already passed financial reform with many of these changes. And the lobbyists are already trying to kill it. Well, we cannot let them win this fight. And if the bill that ends up on my desk does not meet the test of real reform, I will send it back.” Dumbstruck, that is: “Raise your hands if you believe there are any circumstances under which this president would veto a financial-regulation bill passed by this Congress.”
— “The most interesting part of the speech is where he threatens to veto any financial bill that doesn’t really take on the banks,” echoed Megan McArdle at the Atlantic.
Related
The State of the Union
Columns, quick takes and the editorial on the president’s 2010 national address.
Commentary From Opinionator »
“The proposals he unveiled last week to limit the size of bank liabilities, and dismantle their proprietary trading desks, were greeted with acclaim by many financial journalists, but it is widely believed that legislators like Senator Dodd will simply kill them in committee. If he’s willing to risk ending up with nothing, that may be smart politics–and perhaps smart regulation. But that’s a very daring move for a president who has so far proved extremely reluctant to take on his congress.”
— Ponnuru’s colleague at the Corner, Kathryn Jean Lopez, had some ungrudging praise: “The President did outright the Right on nuclear power plants. So many have given up on that issue.”
— Andrew Sullivan had a similar observation: “His energy program sounds a lot like McCain’s in the campaign: all of the above. And drill, baby, drill! But I love this: clean energy is worth doing whatever you think of climate change. Plenty of conservatives should be able to support this if they could get past their partisanship and bile.” But Sullivan thinks style confidently trumped substance: “I’m struck by how relaxed he seems. Smiling, confident, easy-going, and yet also deadly serious. He’s certainly a lot calmer than most of his supporters, including me. I was a bit of a wreck before this after such a depressing couple of weeks. But he is managing to lift that gloom - not by dazzling rhetoric, but by a form of realism that is reassuring.”
— Regarding the president’s comment that reforming health care wasn’t a fight he was aching for, Ana Marie Cox of GQ notes that his spokesman like to say “he didn’t take on health care because it’s his hobby.” “But, you know, it sort of does feel like it’s a hobby to him, no?” asks Cox. “He tinkers, and pauses, puts it away, moves his own deadline, goes back to the drawing board…”
— For Allahpundit of Hot Air, the most striking claim from the White House came earlier in day, when Obama spokesman Robert Gibbs appeared on Good Morning America. “Many of the same factors that led Sen. [Scott] Brown to become a senator from Massachusetts led Barack Obama to become president,” insisted Gibbs. “Now, we’ve got to deal with those angers and frustrations by putting people back to work, by demonstrating we have a plan to get our economy continued on the road to recovery and putting those folks back to work, and protecting our country from those who seek to do us harm.” Allahpundit’s response: “The One has always enjoyed psychoanalyzing American voters — look no further than his massively overhyped speech on race — but watching him explain to Massachusetts that they were actually kinda sorta voting for him when they voted for Scott Brown should make this his most entertaining soliloquy yet.”
— There was big applause for the president’s line that “I will work with Congress and our military to finally repeal the law that denies gay Americans the right to serve the country they love because of who they are,” but Tanya Domi, a former Army captain writing at Pam’s House Blend, didn’t think that fellow gay men and lesbians should show much gratitude for the rather vague pledge.
Our community, including any Democratic voter who supported you in November 2008 would expect you to sign a hate crimes act into law. This is a given by any Democratic president and surely those inside the Beltway would call signing a hate crimes bill as “low hanging fruit.”
And yet the President once again throws out a few crumbs to our community, announcing to the entire country that there will be no reversal to a discriminatory law for the time being that continues to place our sisters and brethren in harms’ way, for more than simply serving in wars, as tragic and dangerous as they are.
This is the change we have been waiting for? Where is the fierce urgency of now, Mr. President? Don’t you hear that trumpet of justice pounding in your ears when military bands play ‘Hail to the Chief’?
Jillian Bandes of TownHall found the president’s shifts between acknowledging ideological differences and criticism of partisanship a bit muddled. “Obama thinks the Citizens United ruling will “usher in” more special interests in Washington. Alito looked a little combative. I think mud wrestling is in order. Hats off to him recognizing that there is a “fundamental difference in ideology” between different political views. He admitted that some politics are irreconcilable, and I think he might’ve even alluded to Thomas Paine, but I’m working my way through a bottle of wine and can’t be completely sure. He referenced Scott Brown for about half a second. Republicans “have to lead” now that Democrats don’t have a supermajority. If leading means holding your ground on that irreconcilable ideology, I’m all for it.”
— “So we’re going to double our exports in five years, are we?” asks Kevin D. Williamson at the Corner. “Well, let’s think about that. Two ways of counting it up:”
In 2008, the total value of U.S. exports was about $1.8 trillion, and the value of our exports was growing at 12 percent per year, according to Commerce. So, left to their own devices, our exports ought to go from about $2 trillion now to about $3.5 trillion over the next five years — not quite double, but 75 percent growth. So, how many billions of dollars are we going to spend to get that last $500 billion in exports? (And that’s not $500 billion in profit, as I understand it, that’s $500 billion in sales.)
Looked at another way: Exports were 13 percent of GDP in 2008. If that’s the metric we’re using, then they’ll need to be 26 percent of GDP in five years to hit Obama’s goal. If the rest of the economy just stood still (and hold on while the English major thinks this through) that means that exports would have to expand by the equivalent of 13 percent of today’s GDP in five years to hit Obama’s goal. In other words, our new exports — just the new ones — would have to be roughly equal in size to the entire U.S. health-care industry today. That does not seem to me especially likely to happen.
If I’m missing something here, let me know.
Feeling the same way was Ezra Klein, who leaves us with a fitting encapsulation of the American political mood: “Rumor has it the State of the Union is today rather than tomorrow to avoid conflicting with the Lost premiere. But my feelings towards one are pretty similar to my feelings towards the other: I’m confused by the most recent plot twists and skeptical that the writers can wrap it all up in one tidy package.”
Source:opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/
— As the president went through his initial laundry list of wishes and causes, Josh Marshall of TPM came to think liberals might not be in such dire political straits: “Listening to this litany, I’m reminded how Republicans are on the wrong side – just politically, let alone on policy — of most signature issues in a populist economic moment. I think there were zero Republicans standing up on any part of Obama’s financial reform agenda — something that polls exceedingly well in addition to being good public policy.”
— Ramesh Ponnuru of National Review was struck by this passage: “The House has already passed financial reform with many of these changes. And the lobbyists are already trying to kill it. Well, we cannot let them win this fight. And if the bill that ends up on my desk does not meet the test of real reform, I will send it back.” Dumbstruck, that is: “Raise your hands if you believe there are any circumstances under which this president would veto a financial-regulation bill passed by this Congress.”
— “The most interesting part of the speech is where he threatens to veto any financial bill that doesn’t really take on the banks,” echoed Megan McArdle at the Atlantic.
Related
The State of the Union
Columns, quick takes and the editorial on the president’s 2010 national address.
Commentary From Opinionator »
“The proposals he unveiled last week to limit the size of bank liabilities, and dismantle their proprietary trading desks, were greeted with acclaim by many financial journalists, but it is widely believed that legislators like Senator Dodd will simply kill them in committee. If he’s willing to risk ending up with nothing, that may be smart politics–and perhaps smart regulation. But that’s a very daring move for a president who has so far proved extremely reluctant to take on his congress.”
— Ponnuru’s colleague at the Corner, Kathryn Jean Lopez, had some ungrudging praise: “The President did outright the Right on nuclear power plants. So many have given up on that issue.”
— Andrew Sullivan had a similar observation: “His energy program sounds a lot like McCain’s in the campaign: all of the above. And drill, baby, drill! But I love this: clean energy is worth doing whatever you think of climate change. Plenty of conservatives should be able to support this if they could get past their partisanship and bile.” But Sullivan thinks style confidently trumped substance: “I’m struck by how relaxed he seems. Smiling, confident, easy-going, and yet also deadly serious. He’s certainly a lot calmer than most of his supporters, including me. I was a bit of a wreck before this after such a depressing couple of weeks. But he is managing to lift that gloom - not by dazzling rhetoric, but by a form of realism that is reassuring.”
— Regarding the president’s comment that reforming health care wasn’t a fight he was aching for, Ana Marie Cox of GQ notes that his spokesman like to say “he didn’t take on health care because it’s his hobby.” “But, you know, it sort of does feel like it’s a hobby to him, no?” asks Cox. “He tinkers, and pauses, puts it away, moves his own deadline, goes back to the drawing board…”
— For Allahpundit of Hot Air, the most striking claim from the White House came earlier in day, when Obama spokesman Robert Gibbs appeared on Good Morning America. “Many of the same factors that led Sen. [Scott] Brown to become a senator from Massachusetts led Barack Obama to become president,” insisted Gibbs. “Now, we’ve got to deal with those angers and frustrations by putting people back to work, by demonstrating we have a plan to get our economy continued on the road to recovery and putting those folks back to work, and protecting our country from those who seek to do us harm.” Allahpundit’s response: “The One has always enjoyed psychoanalyzing American voters — look no further than his massively overhyped speech on race — but watching him explain to Massachusetts that they were actually kinda sorta voting for him when they voted for Scott Brown should make this his most entertaining soliloquy yet.”
— There was big applause for the president’s line that “I will work with Congress and our military to finally repeal the law that denies gay Americans the right to serve the country they love because of who they are,” but Tanya Domi, a former Army captain writing at Pam’s House Blend, didn’t think that fellow gay men and lesbians should show much gratitude for the rather vague pledge.
Our community, including any Democratic voter who supported you in November 2008 would expect you to sign a hate crimes act into law. This is a given by any Democratic president and surely those inside the Beltway would call signing a hate crimes bill as “low hanging fruit.”
And yet the President once again throws out a few crumbs to our community, announcing to the entire country that there will be no reversal to a discriminatory law for the time being that continues to place our sisters and brethren in harms’ way, for more than simply serving in wars, as tragic and dangerous as they are.
This is the change we have been waiting for? Where is the fierce urgency of now, Mr. President? Don’t you hear that trumpet of justice pounding in your ears when military bands play ‘Hail to the Chief’?
Jillian Bandes of TownHall found the president’s shifts between acknowledging ideological differences and criticism of partisanship a bit muddled. “Obama thinks the Citizens United ruling will “usher in” more special interests in Washington. Alito looked a little combative. I think mud wrestling is in order. Hats off to him recognizing that there is a “fundamental difference in ideology” between different political views. He admitted that some politics are irreconcilable, and I think he might’ve even alluded to Thomas Paine, but I’m working my way through a bottle of wine and can’t be completely sure. He referenced Scott Brown for about half a second. Republicans “have to lead” now that Democrats don’t have a supermajority. If leading means holding your ground on that irreconcilable ideology, I’m all for it.”
— “So we’re going to double our exports in five years, are we?” asks Kevin D. Williamson at the Corner. “Well, let’s think about that. Two ways of counting it up:”
In 2008, the total value of U.S. exports was about $1.8 trillion, and the value of our exports was growing at 12 percent per year, according to Commerce. So, left to their own devices, our exports ought to go from about $2 trillion now to about $3.5 trillion over the next five years — not quite double, but 75 percent growth. So, how many billions of dollars are we going to spend to get that last $500 billion in exports? (And that’s not $500 billion in profit, as I understand it, that’s $500 billion in sales.)
Looked at another way: Exports were 13 percent of GDP in 2008. If that’s the metric we’re using, then they’ll need to be 26 percent of GDP in five years to hit Obama’s goal. If the rest of the economy just stood still (and hold on while the English major thinks this through) that means that exports would have to expand by the equivalent of 13 percent of today’s GDP in five years to hit Obama’s goal. In other words, our new exports — just the new ones — would have to be roughly equal in size to the entire U.S. health-care industry today. That does not seem to me especially likely to happen.
If I’m missing something here, let me know.
Feeling the same way was Ezra Klein, who leaves us with a fitting encapsulation of the American political mood: “Rumor has it the State of the Union is today rather than tomorrow to avoid conflicting with the Lost premiere. But my feelings towards one are pretty similar to my feelings towards the other: I’m confused by the most recent plot twists and skeptical that the writers can wrap it all up in one tidy package.”
Source:opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
